Status & Trends Posts

Reports of salt marsh loss in Buzzards Bay

Last year we received a call from a Bourne resident concerned about a die-off of vegetation in the Patuisset salt marsh in Bourne. A review of aerial images shows a continuous loss of the marsh over many decades, but the rate of loss appeared more pronounced during the past decade.  The March 1995 and October 2016 aerial photographs of the Patuisset marsh in Fig. 1 show a stark difference in both channel widths, and the amount of vegetation near the marsh channel banks.

Comparison of the extent of Patuisset salt marsh in Bourne between March 1995 (top), and October 2016 (bottom.

Fig. 1. Comparison of the extent of Patuisset salt marsh in Bourne between March 1995 (top), and October 2016 (bottom). Note both the widening of channels, and the dramatic loss of vegetation away from the channels.

Recently CZM’s South Coast Regional Coordinator, Dave Janik, provided these photographs of an apparent die back of vegetation away from the creek banks of a salt marsh in Mattapoisett (Fig. 2).

Loss of vegetation along a salt marsh bank in Mattapoisett, observed June 21, 2017. Photo by Dave Janik.

Fig. 2. Loss of vegetation along a salt marsh bank in Mattapoisett, observed June 21, 2017. This pattern of loss is consistent with damage caused by the purple marsh crab. Click to enlarge. Photo credit: Dave Janik.

As noted in the Buzzards Bay Coalition’s article Study shows Westport Rivers losing salt marshes at an accelerating rate, and our own posting, the loss of salt marshes can occur for many reasons.  Since the last ice age, sea level rise has caused the continued loss or migration of salt marshes inland, but at many sites, new losses exceed that expected from sea level rise alone.  Studies elsewhere in the region of rapid marsh loss and die-off have pointed to causes that include population explosions of the purple marsh crab (Sesarma reticulatum) and nitrogen pollution. The articles below have information about the subject for a general audience. If you know a site in Buzzards Bay with salt marsh die-off, please email photographs or information to tracy.warncke@state.ma.us.

Additional Reading

Salt Marsh Dieback and the Purple Marsh Crab on Nantucket

The Not-So-Mysterious Loss of Salt Marshes and Ecosystem Services

Wikipedia: Salt marsh die-off

Falmouth video on benefits oyster aquaculture to water quality

Oyster population counts in West Falmouth Harbor during the spring of 2016.

Oyster population counts in West Falmouth Harbor during the spring of 2016.

Through the U.S. EPA’s SNEP program, the Buzzards Bay NEP awarded a grant to the Town of Falmouth to evaluate water quality benefits of oyster aquaculture (the project was titled “West Falmouth Harbor Oyster Reef Development Project”; see our award announcement). The grant paid for this video, and helped fund a study of the effectiveness of using oyster aquaculture to help mitigate nitrogen pollution.  The project was sited in West Falmouth Harbor, which is the subject of a watershed nitrogen TMDL issued by EPA and the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection. The video highlights the town’s oyster aquaculture program and describes the benefits of oysters to water quality, and was part of the project’s outreach campaign.  You can also read the project’s final report (WF-Oyster-Bed-Final-Report-4-24-17) that includes estimates of nitrogen removal through the harvest of shellfish. The Town of Falmouth considered the pilot project a success and expanded oyster aquaculture efforts in West Falmouth Harbor during 2016. Oyster rafts are visible in the Snug Harbor area of West Falmouth Harbor in the Google Maps 2016 imagery available at this link: https://goo.gl/maps/QCAH5Xu2eVA2.

 

1500 Bags of Remote Set Delivered by Falmouth Staff to Staging Area of Snug Harbor Installation Site

In 2015, 1500 bags of oyster remote set was delivered by Town of Falmouth staff to the staging area at Snug Harbor in West Falmouth Harbor.

 

Westport Salt Marsh Loss Study

NEP Technical Report Documenting Salt Marsh Loss in Westport, MA

Figure from the Westport salt marsh loss technical report.

Figure from the Westport salt marsh loss technical report.

The Buzzards Bay NEP has released a technical report documenting the loss of salt marsh on six islands in the West Branch of the Westport River.  The analysis was undertaken in partnership with the Buzzards Bay Coalition, the Westport River Fisherman’s Association, and scientists at the Woods Hole Research Center. The collaborative study was initiated because of reports of apparent rapid salt marsh loss in the West Branch of the Westport River. The Buzzards Bay NEP was the lead on the historical analysis, which included an evaluation of aerial photographs between 1938 and 2016, a 2016 unmanned aerial vehicle survey in October 2016, and a 1934 nautical chart. The NEP provided both training to Buzzards Bay Coalition staff in digitizing salt marsh boundaries, and performed the GIS analysis of the historical changes. The report describes in detail the GIS methodologies used, and their limitations. This work complimented a companion study of field studies of marsh biomass, and evaluation of water quality trends, to better understand the causes of the recent salt marsh losses. The Buzzards Bay NEP report is available at this link: Costa & Weiner, 2017.

Since the end of the last ice age, over long periods, rising sea level has caused salt marshes to migrate into uplands. In the case of marsh islands studied, except for one, there is no upland area for the marsh to migrate into. The Costa and Weiner study found that while the rate of salt mash loss on the islands was generally linear for much of the twentieth century, there appeared to be an acceleration of marsh loss during the past decade. In addition, the rates of loss varied among the islands, likely due to initial marsh elevations, proximity to river channels, and other factors.  The report estimates the approximate dates of when each of the islands may disappear if recent rates of loss continue.

Jakuba et at. (2017, unpublished) incorporated the data from the Costa and Weiner study into a more comprehensive analysis of potential causes of marsh loss that included field data of salt marsh above and below ground biomass, water quality data, and other field observations. The authors concluded that nitrogen pollution in the Westport River was a contributing factor to the loss of salt marsh area on the islands. A summary of the findings of the Jakuba study is at the Buzzards Bay Coalition Website, and their report to the public is at this link: Salt-Marsh-Loss-in-the-Westport-Rivers.pdf.

Loss in area of the salt marsh island Bailey Flat in the west Branch of the Westport River, 1934-2016.

Loss in area of the salt marsh island Bailey Flat between 1934 and 2016.